This group is specifically for reviews of individual comic books, graphic novels/trade paperbacks, and manga.

All posts will be moderated. The objective is to compile a searchable collection of comic book reviews rated on a consistent scale. Therefore, . . .

This group is specifically for reviews of individual comic books, graphic novels/trade paperbacks, and manga.

All posts will be moderated. The objective is to compile a searchable collection of comic book reviews rated on a consistent scale. Therefore, all posts should adhere to the following:

Each individual book must individually identified.

Each book should be rated on a 1-10 scale (1 is worst, 10 is best). The individual reviewer is welcome to set their own parameters for what constitutes a specific rating. Some group members might be "easier" graders than others. That's fine.

For small press and independent books, please provide a link back to the publisher if possible (especially if you liked the book).

You are welcome to review multiple books per article, but please include each title and publisher in the tags. Reviewers are encouraged to also include tags for names of writers/artists, main characters, crossover tie-ins, etc. for each book you review.

Because I will be entering stats from all reviews into a spreadsheet, please allow a bit more time than usual for your review to post.

Please avoid foul language. Even if the book really deserved it.

Keep the discussion fun and civil.